With practice
almost anyone can complete a marathon (with lots of huffs and puffs). But
winning a NY city marathon is a different ball game. I believe that the genetic
makeup too plays a key role in there not just practice. Same is the case with
any game of sports or arts. Preforming at the top level is not mere practice or
willingness to work hard. It is a gift. I have heard that some people have
inborn talents in mathematics. They love to ‘play with numbers’. Many great
scientists in mathematics, physics and statistics were like that. I don’t think
great minds of the Einstein or Feynman could come up with the ideas they put
forwarded by mere PhD training. The genetic program must have played an
important role in it. Equally important is the right environment that would
nurture the inborn talents. I work in the area of life science, where timing
and mathematical skills may not seem a necessary gift. I was wondering what
kind of ‘neural circuits’ one has to develop to be considered as a genius in my
field of study?
First of all who
is a genius? The dictionary definition of genius is ‘a person with extraordinary
intellectual power especially as manifested in creative activity’. In science,
a broad definition of a genius is ‘someone with an extraordinary ability to
make important observations and use that information to come up with original
ideas’. Charles Darwin and Gregory Mendel are very good examples of that kind.
Their observations and theories revolutionized biology. One can argue that
neither Darwin nor Mendel started with an in depth knowledge in their field of
research. So, another important trait of this group is creativity and deep curiosity (these are the defining qualities of any real scientists). To use the data at hand to
make a story; like an artist who chisels away unwanted part of a stone to make
a sculpture (well, I don't mean that you omit data that don't support your hypothesis to come up with story, but weld together the available data to generate an idea). The boldness to propose a theory, even if it challenges the
prevailing belief system (at least in case of Darwin, who had undergone a lot
of mental struggle to publish a book that would challenge 'The Bible') is a
defining feature of this group. This is the first category, ‘the theorists’.
There is another
group who propel the science forward by developing new technology. Polymerase
Chain Reaction (PCR) was a very good example. Sanger sequencing, Reverse
transcriptase, X-ray crystallography, Restriction endonucleases. But many of
these discoveries are group efforts. And in many cases the scientists never
could imagine its future application when they discovered or invented something. But I
will categorize these groups of people, who devise a revolutionary technology
that allow science to evolve to next phase, as geniuses. For example, I cannot imagine how
my research would have been if PCR or restriction enzymes were not around. So
this is the second category of genius biologists, ‘the inventors’, who develop
a technology and use it to change the way research is done.
Then there is a
group who are the experts in their field of study. They know everything about
the subject area, the past, present and probably little bit of future. This is
the largest group of geniuses. I believe that, in biomedical research the first
and foremost thing one need is a deep knowledge in their respective field of
study. It’s not about mere accumulation of information but about parsing that
information to make connections, sometime very far fetched, and most
importantly to identify what is missing from the picture. It is the missing
part where the opportunity lies. Once you know pretty much everything about
your area of research and the history of it, you will have a very good idea of
where it is heading, or where it should be heading. When you have a lot of
solid information at hand you can make educated guesses and invest your money
where the market will be in next few years. The odds of winning the bet are
very high, especially when you have insider information. They may be getting
such insider information by working with other smart colleagues. It helps them
to strategize their research direction. It’s an unfair advantage, but lets face
it, its not always a fair world either. They are ‘the innovators’.
There may be more categories or subcategories or
overlapping categories to the three groups we described. Each one is important.
The first two categories may be a natural gift, that is, ‘born geniuses’. The
third category gives hope for anyone who is interested in science, that is, if you are extremely passionate about what you does and develop certain skills, one day the world will see you also
as a genius. You can train yourself to become a genius, which may not be possible
in case of arts or literature or maths. That makes biology unique, in the sense
that it gives you an opportunity to excel, if you are willing to work hard
enough. I mean really, really, very, very hard!! Each category of scientists
makes their own contributions in unique ways. A genius in biological sciences
may be different in their skill sets and aptitude than those in some other
areas of research. But to me anyone who see the opportunity that no one else
see and figure out a real life puzzle before other smart peoples around do, is
a genius.
Image courtesy:
CharlesDarwin: http://www.boriskulikov.com/DarwinTreeOfLife.html
Gregory Mendel: http://undsci.berkeley.edu/article/0_0_0/endosymbiosis_04
