Punjab, one of the economically well off and educated state in India is on fire. Reason: a religious leader of one of the sikh faction was killed in Vienna. I was listening to one of the di
scussions on that matter and according to one of the participants in the discussion, what is happening in Jalandhar is nothing but a "usual behavior of people in India". One thing that confused me in the beginning was who were the conflicting parties. If a Sikh priest was being killed by another Sikh, then who is waging war against whom in the streets of Punjab ??
scussions on that matter and according to one of the participants in the discussion, what is happening in Jalandhar is nothing but a "usual behavior of people in India". One thing that confused me in the beginning was who were the conflicting parties. If a Sikh priest was being killed by another Sikh, then who is waging war against whom in the streets of Punjab ??During my two years stay in Punjab I had the opportunity to understand the Sikh religion through books and also through my Sikh friends. Just like any other religion Sikhism is also a religion based on great principles. Majority of Sikhs whom I met were very generous and cordial individuals. It is a very young religion originated in 16th century based on the teachings of Guru Nanak and other Gurus who succeeded him. I could see many components of Hinduism and Sufism in it (I do not have any reference regarding 'sufism' base in Sikhism, that could be just my observation; many people do not consider Sufism as an independent religion). Most of the initial followers of Guru Nanak were peasants and unorganised farmers and Sikhism gave them an identity. Sikhism was also a revolution against casteism that was existed in Hinduism during that period. The point is that in the beginning there were no disparity among the members of Sikhism. All were equal, more or less. However, during the process of social evolution diversity came up and along came disparities. Now there are higher "caste" Sikhs, lower caste Dalit sikhs, there are multitudes of 'Deras', cults and divisions among Sikh religion. Whats going on in Punjab right now is the clash between two such 'Groups'. I do not know the politics behind it, nor am I interested in it. All I want to convey is the picture of a relatively young monotheic religion, which was established as protest against casteism and disparity.
It is an opportunity for an interesting social study. Many movements originate on the foundation of great principles, to achieve a great cause and to suppress social injustice. But in almost all cases things would change eventually. When a cause is achieved the fundamentals would be changed, when the leadership changes goals and principles would be altered. Many a times its only the name that remain unchanged. I have many friends of other religious believes who tells the absence of cast system in their religion as one of the plus points of their respective religion as against Sanathana Dharma (incorrectly identified as Hinduism) which I practice (Casteism also is the negative result of a social evolution that happened over centuries, created by the misinterpretation of scriptures by the educated class). But, honestly, I haven't seen any religious or social movements or organization (which is at least 3 generations old) that do not have some sort of factions or groups which are fighting against each other, than against other belief groups.
In Christianity, there are people who worship Christ, Mary or only Jahoa, there are innumerable groups of Catholics, Orthodox, Protestants, Pentecost and many more. Many factions have even waged outright wars against other groups. Many a times 'inter groups' marriages are strongly discouraged and some groups even hate to visit the churches of other groups. In Islam, I do not have to tell you the level of 'friendship' that exist between Sunnis and Shias. There are at least three or four school of thoughts of Buddhism.
Well, it is not a phenomenon unique to religions, there are multitude of groups and sub groups in Communism, which came up to emancipate the working class from the clutches of feudalism and imperialism. In the beginning all were equal, eventually some turned out to be more equal than others!! During my 'atheistic life' I was exposed to the cheap politics and backstabbing that was going on among and within some atheist associations in India.
So, such differences are the results of social evolution, which has its roots at the individual level. Most of it has nothing to do with the original organization or principles on which various institutions were established. In most cases such divisions came up due to selfish attitudes of individuals (in most cases the reasons for the cause of conflict would be forgotten during the long course of time, the individuals who caused such factions would be dead and rotten, what generally remain would be the hatred in the minds of peoples).
Selfishness is encoded in genome of all living creature, I believe
. We all might be nothing but the vehicles for "selfish genes" (Thanks to Dr. Richard Dawkins). Whatever that belongs to me should be propagated, my genes, my blood, my thoughts, my name , my, I, mine.... yes that is the nature of life. That is the force which drives a male black widow spider to mate even it has to sacrifice its life, that is the force which cover the bacteria as thick spore, that is the force which give strength to pacific salmons to swim hundreds of miles to spawn and arctic terns to fly thousands of miles every year without fail. The unabatable craving to survive and perpetuate ones own genes.
. We all might be nothing but the vehicles for "selfish genes" (Thanks to Dr. Richard Dawkins). Whatever that belongs to me should be propagated, my genes, my blood, my thoughts, my name , my, I, mine.... yes that is the nature of life. That is the force which drives a male black widow spider to mate even it has to sacrifice its life, that is the force which cover the bacteria as thick spore, that is the force which give strength to pacific salmons to swim hundreds of miles to spawn and arctic terns to fly thousands of miles every year without fail. The unabatable craving to survive and perpetuate ones own genes.Is that all ?? Are we nothing but a bunch of selfish entities who wants to be propagated indefinitely at any cost? Then what is love, compassion and altruism ? I can not explain all these qualities without adding a spiritual component to life, at least for the time being. It could be the limitation of current science; it is the scope too. Understanding the body, mind and the driving force of all these living entities is the true challenge to scientists.
A world with equality and social justice to all, a world of absolute peace and tranquility, a world were all are happy and satisfied, will come about only in fairy tales. It is a reality that we have to live with. With a better understanding about the functioning of brain, it would be possible to manipulate peoples thoughts and emotions. You may have a fair and perfect world artificially projected in mind. But knowing the basic instincts of living creatures, such a world will never come into existence.
These are not doomed prophecies from a pessimistic mind. But I prefer to be realistic rather than being in a fools paradise. These are certain facts that we may have to live with. But an awareness of human behaviour and animal instincts will help us to be better prepared to face realities and accept unfair events with a fair mind. I have strong faith in humanity. I have witnessed great sacrifices and instance of true altruism by ordinary peoples. These feelings are real, these people are real. The only explanation that I have now is the spiritual dimension. A force that links everything together, call it love, Higgs bosons, God or Brahma, as you may please. As Gita says...
"Mattah parataram nanyat
kincid asti dhananjaya
mayi sarvam idam protam
sutre mani-gana iva"
(..there is nothing superior to Me. Everything that exists are connected by me as pearls are strung on a thread").
The life is a quest to realize that thread, the Me in me. Some are fortunate to realize that, some may get glimpse of the truth, but the majority will never realize even the existence of such a question. Whatever the case will be, may the force be with you !!!!
Picture courtesy:

I remember you telling me that this "selfishness" of propagating "the me" identity is what sustains creation. So looks like the other negative side of "craving to continue one's own identity" . It is such an interesting topic.
ReplyDeleteThats true. But an ideal life is gonna be boring. I do not consider selfishness as a totally negative feeling. It is an attitude required for survival. Any living being alive is selfish to varying extent (there would be enough oppurtunities in everyones life for an absolute sacrifice; conversely, if one is alive it means he or she has declined that chance for selfish motives). Its not bad, but in excess could be deleterious just like anything else.
ReplyDelete